Best Chew Toys for Teething Puppies (2026 Expert Picks)

Now that we know what a teething puppy needs from a toy, it’s time to find the products that actually fit those standards. The toys below were selected using the same criteria from the first guide — safe hardness, correct size, non-toxic materials, soothing textures, cooling options, and realistic puppy durability.

Best Chew Toys for Teething Puppies in 2026

How we picked the best chew toys for teething puppies

I built this 2026 list around three nonnegotiables: safety, real teething relief, and durability for the price. Every toy here was chosen based on:

· Material safety: nontoxic, BPAfree, phthalatefree, no sharp edges, and puppysafe hardness.

· Teething performance: does it actually soothe gums, keep puppies busy, and survive repeated chewing.

· Breed fit: options that work for toy breeds up to large, aggressive chewer pups.

· Ease of use: easy to clean, easy to grip, and simple for owners to use daily.

· Global availability & value: products you can actually buy in most regions, without insane prices.

Minardipets FreezeBone™ Cooling Teething Stick

This is my goto cooling teething toy for puppies that are really struggling with gum pain.

Why it works:

· Freezable core that holds the cold longer than a wet cloth or basic rubber toy.

· Soft, textured natural rubber for gentle gum massage without damaging baby teeth.

· Lightweight shape that’s easy for small and medium puppies to carry and gnaw.

· Nontoxic, BPAfree materials, built specifically for teething pups, not adult power chewers.

Best for: hot climates, soremouth days, and puppies that love chilled textures and freezeable puppy teething toys.

KONG Puppy Goodie Bone

KONG’s puppy line is a classic for a reason. The Puppy Goodie Bone is softer than their adult toys and perfect for young mouths.

Key benefits:

· Soft vs hard chew balance: firm enough to last, but still gentle on baby teeth.

· Treatdispensing ends you can stuff with soft puppy treats or a smear of puppysafe paste.

· KONG puppy rubber designed for teething relief and light to medium chewers.

· Good for crate training, boredom, and redirecting chewing away from furniture.

Best for: most small to medium puppies, especially those that love food rewards and KONG puppy toys.

Nylabone Puppy Teething Pacifier

The Nylabone Puppy Teething Pacifier hits that sweet spot between gum massage and fun texture.

Why I like it:

· Multiple textures and nubs for gum stimulation and plaque scraping.

· Softer puppygrade nylon, not the rockhard adult chews.

· Ring and pacifier shapes are easy for puppies to paw, toss, and carry.

· Light flavoring encourages healthy chewing instead of biting shoes.

Best for: small and medium puppies that love to “worry” a toy for long sessions and need puppy dental health toys.

Benebone Puppy Wishbone

Benebone took their wellknown adult chew and made a puppyspecific, gentler version.

Highlights:

· Puppysoft nylon blend that’s safer for young teeth than standard hard nylon.

· Ergonomic wishbone design that puppies can hold between their paws.

· Realflavor infusions (like bacon or chicken) to keep interest high.

· Great for aggressive chewer puppies who still need a softer chew than adult Benebones.

Best for: medium and large breed puppies, and strong chewers that already destroy basic rubber toys.

West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Tough Chew Toy

The Zogoflex Hurley is your “tough but still puppyfriendly” option.

Why it stands out:

· Recyclable, nontoxic Zogoflex material that’s durable yet slightly flexible.

· Boneshaped, great for fetch, tug, and solo chewing.

· Dishwashersafe, which matters when you’re cleaning up after a teething tornado.

· Safer alternative to sticks and random household objects.

Best for: medium to large breed puppies and owners who care about ecofriendly puppy chew toys.

Petstages Cool Teething Stick

This one is built for cooling teething relief and light chewers.

Key features:

· Fabric and gel design that can be soaked and frozen for extra cooling.

· Crunchy, crinkly feel that keeps puppies engaged.

· Great for soothing inflamed gums during peak teething weeks.

Best for: gentle chewers and smaller puppies that love softer, fabricstyle cooling teething toys for dogs.

Minardipets Natural Rubber Puppy Dumbbell

This is my workhorse natural rubber puppy toy that’s built specifically around teething needs.

Why I rate it highly:

· 100% natural rubber, free from BPA, phthalates, and harsh chemicals.

· Dumbbell shape with textured bumps for gum massage and better grip.

· Balanced hardness: soft enough for teething, tough enough for daily use.

· Easy to clean and holds up nicely even with energetic chewers.

Best for: global dog owners who want a nontoxic puppy chew toy that can handle daily chewing and fetch without falling apart.

Hartz Chew ’n Clean Teething Ring

The Chew ’n Clean Teething Ring combines texture variety and light dental support.

Pros:

· Ring shape encourages fullmouth chewing, which helps with jaw exercise.

· Multiple textures for interest and gum massage.

· Satisfies puppies that like to chew and tug in all directions.

Best for: small and medium puppies that enjoy rings and squeaky teething toys for puppies (depending on variant).

Ruff Dawg Indestructible Ball

No toy is truly “indestructible,” but the Ruff Dawg Ball is one of the toughest on this list, while still safer than ultrahard toys for young dogs.

Why it made the list:

· Solid, rubbery build that’s tough yet bouncy.

· Good for fetchobsessed puppies and outdoor play.

· Floats and is easy to clean.

· Best introduced when your puppy’s mouth can handle a bit more resistance (late teething stage).

Best for: medium and large breed pups, future retrievers, and highenergy breeds like Labradors and doodles that need both chewing and chasing.

Honorable mentions: budget & ecofriendly picks

If you’re on a budget or want greener options, here are solid backups:

· Basic natural rubber rings and bones from reputable brands (look for “puppy” on the label and BPAfree, nontoxic claims).

· Recycled rubber toys for ecominded owners.

· Simple rope toys (only under supervision) to satisfy tug and chew urges at a low price.

Pairing great chew toys with good walking gear—like a nopull harness and a safe lead—helps control your puppy’s energy and reduce destructive chewing. If you’re kitting out your puppy’s essentials, it’s worth matching these toys with secure, comfortable gear like the best nopull dog harnesses from 2026 that are designed for growing dogs: best nopull dog harnesses 2026.

Durability, safety & value comparison

Here’s the quick view of how these best chew toys for teething puppies in 2026 stack up:

Softest, most soothing:

lMinardipets FreezeBone™ Cooling Teething Stick

lPetstages Cool Teething Stick

Balanced teething + durability:

lKONG Puppy Goodie Bone

lMinardipets Natural Rubber Puppy Dumbbell

lNylabone Puppy Teething Pacifier

Tougher for strong chewers (later teething stages):

lBenebone Puppy Wishbone

lWest Paw Zogoflex Hurley

lRuff Dawg Indestructible Ball

Best value picks:

lMinardipets Natural Rubber Puppy Dumbbell

lHartz Chew ’n Clean Teething Ring

lKONG Puppy Goodie Bone

My rule: start softer, then level up as your puppy’s adult teeth come in and their chewing power increases. Rotate 3–5 of these toys so your puppy always has a safe, interesting option instead of your shoes.

Choosing a toy is only half the job — you also need the right size, training approach, chew style match, and safety habits. Continue here:

How to Choose and Use Teething Chew Toys for Puppies (Training, Safety & FAQs)